comparison of webpages

[1der]

Comparing Designs
Which of these two home pages do ye think are better?
please give a reason why you think the one you choose is better.

http://www.munsterrugby.ie/ (http://www.munsterrugby.ie/)
or
http://uggie.murphy.googlepages.com/Munster.htm (http://uggie.murphy.googlepages.com/Munster.htm)
(not all links are updated)

[emmerse]

number one by far

better images, better font, better layout, better... um, everything

and number two is loaded with spelling errors.

[shadepics]

ummm toughie... number one maybe?

[EC]

1.

[chris_bcn]

1.

2 made my eyes hurt tbh

On an unrelated note - it's 5 and I'm going home!

Admitedly I'll be going to my office at home to carry on working, but I will at least be able to have a coupl eof glasses of wine while I do it

[1der]

good stuff.
now compare this one if ye can.
http://uggie.murphy.googlepages.com/muns2.htm

[chris_bcn]

sorry that's just not very good at all. NAvigation is not fully visible until you mouseover, and then when you click on one it jumps back to its start point and I don't want to ahve to chase my links across the page.

[cjoe]

er, 1.

[G-Man79]

^echo all that. #1 looks professional, #2 looks juvenile.