One thing I notice immediately about all of these is that the loop in the key is the largest object and thus is the focal point of the logo, drawing attention away from everything else.
I think out of all of them, 1 is best, but it still needs some tweaking. My eye starts at the "O" and leads right to the "KH" without picking up "Kari Howell Realtor". There's nothing that leads my eye to this text.
In 2 and 3, you break the flow of the logo with the text. In 4, it looks like two separate logos.
What if you made "Kari Howell Realtor" the logo without the key, similar to the right side of #4? Or do you need the key?
She was pretty keen on the key, the whole idea of her being "The Key to Your New Home", that is kind of the tag line we are running with. I agree with the loop being a little to heavy.
Thanks for the feedback.
On a side note, if a printer were to tell you:
"captured at a minimum of 300dpi, stored at 24 but TIFF files)
The key is clever. Try using a regular serif instead of that slab serif in the key letters. They'r a little bit obvious because of their lack of brackets (the joint between the main stroke and the serif).
That whole key logo, like everyone said, should be thinned down. It's jarring and stealing the attention. Try standing it upright and running all the text real clean right next to it.
Those, of course, are just suggestions, no way to know if they're good or not without seeing it. Overall just try to avoid too much words overlapping objects, words contained inside objects, obscure top and bottom alignments, it gives it all a thrown together look. Certainly a solid start, though.
i agree about the loop on the end of the key. maybe make it another shape &/or make it smaller. i like the text inside of key on #2 but not sure about the name. but it's my favorite. good work. keep us up to date.
Steeler Born, Steeler Bred And When I Die I'll be Steeler Dead!
The design field not regulating itself is a big problem. I've quit freelancing because there is so much competition from high school kids sitting in their parents basement using pirated copies of Photoshop...
I created a visiting card in illustrator with cmyk color mode. then publish it to pdf but when i got my printout got color shift problem, the color i chose in illustrator for visiting card has changed....