Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Is this one good?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Is this one good?

    I went with the more suttle look:

    http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y23...er/gilmore.gif

  • #2
    i am working on a critique right now... but firstly why does the word 'best' start with a capital? sorry i'm being picky until i can come up with something constructive.
    I work while you are all asleep...

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by cjoe
      i am working on a critique right now... but firstly why does the word 'best' start with a capital? sorry i'm being picky until i can come up with something constructive.
      Yep! Thats a big error! Thanks! I'll fix that.
      http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y23...er/gilmore.gif

      Comment


      • #4
        This one is good. Subtle is good. Did you put in the blurry effect at the edges. I didn't think that you should've gotten rid of the other one though, I just wanted to know why you made it in a punk style. Also I think you could've organized the content better and not just use filters and add stuff for the heck of it. I liked the font effect in the first one. I know you're just learning, keep at it, photoshop is a huge program. I've been using it for 6 years and still probably know less then 1% off its capabilities. Editing photos like this is good practice. Oh and also I think it's ('til) not ('till) the (') is used to replace the (u) in until. Do you know what leading is yet (pronounced led ding)? It's the space between sentences in point sizes. Here I think it's too spaced out. In this case it looks like you have it at about 16pt maybe for the text. Well next to the point size in the character window in photoshop is the leading size, decrease that until the 2 text lines are closer. Good job!!

        Comment


        • #5
          It's 'til or until.
          Creativity is taking what is and bringing in what isn't.

          Comment


          • #6
            its very sentimental, the blurring next to the young chicks head is uneven, it seems like there is a chunk out of her head. Only minor technical stuff.
            Try repositioning the text, you might be able to get a more dynamic effect it seems a little static in the middle. I'm not sure how exactly you should follow this rule but check to see if the girls eyes line up on the thirds of the page. search for photography 'rule of thirds' on google, there should be some stuff on it.
            I work while you are all asleep...

            Comment


            • #7
              this one i like as is.

              contrary to popular belief I belive the capical "B" is working compositionally... even though it does not conform to the correct rules of grammer. The capital B is emphasising the best.

              The letting is a bit off and type attributes have some promblems as keith mentioned. However... i didn't know what leading even was untill about a year ago.

              so i'll let that one slide,lol
              Last edited by tZ; 06-16-2005, 07:38 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by tZ
                this one i like as is.

                contrary to popular belief I belive the capical "B" is working compositionally... even though it does not conform to the correct rules of grammer. The capictal B is emphasising the best.
                good point.
                I work while you are all asleep...

                Comment


                • #9
                  I really liked the green one. But I know nothing. The two f's below her chin kind of bring my attention there and make her chin look like its popping out more. Once again, I just started using p.s. a few months ago.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    My only crit is the blur on the girls head (on the right side). I think it's too heavy, and you can see a definite squared shape to it, which gives it an un-natural look.

                    Apart from that, i really like it!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      sailedship not bad I had read up alittle on you and how you wanted to learn how to use filters. Well this is pretty good, looks simple and clean.

                      When I was learning Design one thing I learned was to start simple then get complicated as you go and learn to create fluid effects. Good Job! And I'm impressed your picking it up so quickly.

                      Comment

                      Search

                      Collapse

                      Sponsor

                      Collapse

                      Incredible Stock

                      Latest Topics

                      Collapse

                      • SabrinaHartford
                        Reply to Feedback on Hawaii dessert (baking) cook book cover
                        SabrinaHartford
                        The actual recipes are a mix of semi-Hawaiian and authentic Hawaiian (e.g. Koi, Haupia and Kulolo are proper Hawaiian Desserts, but then Manju Cake, Bibingka Cake, Chocolate Tofu Mousse pie and Hawaiian...
                        Today, 02:42 AM
                      • B
                        Comment on [HELO] Convert web image for billboard
                        B
                        Well, who knows. They might have their reasons that would make sense if we knew them.

                        You're right, though, it's their money and if that's what they insist they want -- despite your best...
                        Yesterday, 09:21 PM
                      • MazeMiami
                        Reply to [HELO] Convert web image for billboard
                        MazeMiami
                        I'm grateful for the time both you spent to inform me and respect your expertise. Didn't mean to sound like I was disregarding what you shared. Just figure if it's not going to make much of a difference...
                        Yesterday, 09:16 PM
                      • B
                        Reply to Get Your Graphic Design License Here
                        B
                        Hmmm, good question. Probably not. Most generally recognized professions seem to have licensing requirements, though, so I guess my comments stem from designers being somehow excluded and the profession...
                        Yesterday, 09:14 PM
                      • MazeMiami
                        Reply to [HELO] Convert web image for billboard
                        MazeMiami
                        No one gave me a solution seems like either way I would get similar results. I suggested the clients use the file we already have in hand and they insisted they wanted vector. I'm open to having the imaged...
                        Yesterday, 09:07 PM
                      GDF A division of Mediabistro Holdings Adweek | Mediabistro | Clio | Film Expo Group Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy Copyright 2016 Mediabistro Holdings
                      Working...
                      X