ArtCraft - has anyone seen this?

Supposed to be open source clones of the entire Adobe suite, rewritten using completely new code

2 Likes

Interesting. It would be nice if there were a free trial. But you have to sign up and pay to try anything. :frowning:

2 Likes

I don’t know anything about them, but it looks like it is free and open source. You can pay for a subscription (but you don’t have to) which includes some benefits and AI.

1 Like

Ahh ok. I clicked on create image and was taken to a subscription page when I tried. :wink:

Interesting find. Before trusting any new “Adobe alternative” with real client work, a few things I’d check: (1) the actual license — plenty of tools market themselves as “open source” while keeping the core code closed, so look for the license text rather than the marketing copy; (2) file portability — can you export layered PSD, print-ready PDF, and SVG files that open cleanly elsewhere, so your work isn’t trapped if the company pivots or shuts down; (3) color management and CMYK support, which is exactly where most new tools fall apart for print work; and (4) where your files live — a browser/cloud tool that stores your projects on its servers is a bigger commitment than a desktop app you can walk away from. Nothing wrong with trying it on a personal project first, but I’d keep the paying work in tools that have already proven themselves on points 2 and 3.

I tried it yesterday - it opened an InDesign file with no drama and with a bit of trial and error I was able to make some amends and export a PDF.

This software is not ready - there are lots of things that don’t work or don’t work well, but this is very close and I believe that it’s potentially a viable alternative to scumbag Adobe. I would happily donate/subscribe to this.

1 Like

Needs a better name. Sounds too amateurish.

eh, whatever. You use it, I’ll have to buy it and learn it (shrug)
Until I don’t care any more. :rofl: Retirement is visible on the horizon

Canva saved me the trouble of learning Affinity.
Now I can say one good thing about Canva.

3 Likes

They are FREE to download. I have tried all the Mac ones. They look OK at first. On the Design ( Indesign) for example you cannot copy and paste text from another program or an emial. Kind of renders the whole program useless. Don’t think all the system fonts are working, still checking. The ilustrator one, will not open excisitng Adobe files, and you cannot open the files created in Adobe, but still checking things. The PDF one seems to be working very well. BUT they are not good enough to replace ADOBE stuff YET !!!

1 Like

I have been testing this “Art” (I would say, just a suggestion stay on Adobe, this software cannot compare with them). I would stay with my Alternatives, and I am still using them. For me Adobe Express is still more useful than this software.

It is basically an Ai generated clone of Adobe products and my YouTube start page is full with ArtCraft videos already. The project is just a week old and almost there.

2 Likes

Adobe Design apps are almost dead but not because of ArtCraft or others.

AI already is so good that soon a lot of people will not use apps anymore. Give it two years.

1 Like

Fair play to anyone willing to invest their time, money and effort into developing something like this and making it available to everyone for free. I think it’s a fascinating experiment in what’s becoming possible with AI-assisted software development.

But creating something that resembles Adobe’s applications is one thing. Developing and maintaining a complete professional software ecosystem is something entirely different.

There are plenty of questions about where this goes next. Will it receive regular updates, bug fixes and security patches? Security patches are particularly interesting for me, am I opening up the computer to malware or anything else?

Will development eventually take its own direction and introduce genuinely new features, or will it always be playing catch-up with Adobe? What happens when operating systems change, hardware evolves or users encounter problems that need urgent attention? Will we eventually see proper support, tablet applications or online collaboration?

Looking at the project’s GitHub roadmap, they’re actually quite open about the limitations. DesignCraft, their InDesign alternative, is currently described as pre-alpha, with the developers estimating it’s only around 47% ready for real professional work. That’s not a criticism, just an indication of how much development is still required.

Coming from a print production background, my biggest concern would be reliability. It’s one thing to create a document that looks correct on screen. It’s another to guarantee accurate colour separations, spot colours, overprints, fonts, bleeds, PDF standards and everything else involved in getting artwork safely through production.

If I’m responsible for artwork going to a million-plus print run, I need confidence that everything is being interpreted and output correctly. If something fails, who do I contact? What’s the support structure, escalation process or guarantee of continued maintenance?

There’s also the bigger issue of established industry workflows. Industries such as pharmaceuticals, packaging, publishing and large corporate environments have invested heavily in Adobe-based systems. They’ve built workflows around scripting, automation, quality control, file compatibility, third-party software and established production procedures. Moving away isn’t simply a matter of installing another application because it’s free.

And it’s not as though Adobe has no competition. Affinity, Scribus, Inkscape, GIMP and plenty of other alternatives have been around for years, some completely free. Yet Adobe remains deeply embedded in many professional environments because of the wider ecosystem and established workflows, not just the applications themselves.

That said, I wouldn’t dismiss ArtCraft. Open-source development could allow it to evolve into something genuinely useful, perhaps even surpassing established applications in particular areas. Its AI automation approach could be especially interesting.

I suppose what interests me most isn’t whether AI can recreate an application that already exists. It’s whether the people behind it can turn that achievement into software that’s reliable, sustainable, properly supported and capable of standing on its own.

It’s an impressive beginning, but there’s a considerable difference between proving something is possible and producing something professionals can depend on every day.


Another thought occurred to me. This might actually benefit Adobe in the long run rather than being a direct threat to them.

Think about how many people historically learned Photoshop, Illustrator or other Adobe applications using cracked versions because they couldn’t afford the software. They’d spend years becoming familiar with the interface, tools and shortcuts, and eventually some would find themselves working in industries where Adobe was already the standard.

ArtCraft could potentially provide that same learning opportunity, except legally and for free.

If it’s genuinely reproducing the Adobe experience, someone interested in graphic design could learn the basics without the subscription costs. By the time they enter employment, they’re already familiar with the environment they’ll be using professionally.

Ironically, that could reinforce Adobe’s position as an industry standard rather than undermine it.

I actually wonder whether ArtCraft might initially be more of a threat to Affinity than Adobe.

Affinity is now free too, and it’s a far more established application, but it has its own interface and approach to working. If you’re learning graphic design specifically to get a job in an Adobe-based environment, wouldn’t it make more sense to learn on something that closely resembles Adobe?

Obviously, that depends on ArtCraft becoming sufficiently accurate and reliable to provide a useful learning experience.

There’s also the possibility that ArtCraft becomes good enough that people never need to move to Adobe at all. And that’s where it could become a genuine competitor.

It’s an interesting situation. The better ArtCraft becomes at reproducing Adobe, the more useful it could be as a training platform, but equally, the less reason people might have to pay for Adobe afterwards.

I suppose time will tell whether it becomes an entry point into the Adobe ecosystem or a serious alternative to it.

But I’d imagine Affinity are more worried than Adobe.

If you want a free alternative to Adobe, why choose Affinity when you’re already familiar with Adobe?

2 Likes

I think this “supposed” ¨Free Artcraft¨ is infesting YouTube, with many videos this happens before with Canvas, when they released affinity for free download. Now the history repeat with a different name is “Art Craft”

Some people don’t learn the lesson, and they wanted to replace Adobe with something new and different, but the history is the same as before with a different new Name and Adobe would not be replaced never ever, they always innovate and add new functionality to their software. I prefer to use the same software as I used before but maybe I will use the same alternatives and experimenting with new software when they are available to experience new things. Use old software and use new software or new tools when they are available.

And more, have a look


here:

1 Like

I thought this was free, too. In addition, I am seeing a lot of errors simply trying to navigate. Perhaps a lot has changed in the last few days?